How MSCI’s “Non-Operating Company” Rule Applies to Bitcoin Treasury Companies, Explained
Stock index providers decide which companies go into the indexes that index funds track. MSCI has spent a year deciding whether companies that mainly hold bitcoin count as operating businesses; its November 2026 review removed Strategy and Metaplanet. This explainer sets out MSCI’s own dated decisions and the screens it uses.
Data as of · MSCI announcements from Oct 10, 2025 to the November 2026 Index Review (announced Nov 11, 2026)
Illustration: MSCI’s six dated decisions on digital asset treasury and non-operating companies, October 2025 to November 2026.
How MSCI’s “Non-Operating Company” Rule Applies to Bitcoin Treasury Companies, Explained, data as of 2026-11-18
Date
Stage
What MSCI announced
Oct 10, 2025
Consultation
Proposal: exclude companies whose digital asset holdings are 50% or more of total assets; freeze on share-count and inclusion-factor increases for Metaplanet and Capital B1
Oct 29, 2025
Consultation
Updated preliminary list of potentially affected securities; same interim treatment applied to the list2
Jan 6, 2026
Decision
Not to implement the 50% exclusion at the February 2026 review; broader consultation on non-operating companies to follow; interim treatment stays3
Aug 3, 2026
Consultation
Proposal: define non-operating companies as ineligible using a core screen and five financial ratios; buffers for current constituents4
Oct 15, 2026
Decision
Proposal implemented with minor modifications at the November 2026 review, effective at the close of Nov 30; interim measures discontinued5
Nov 11, 2026
Review result
November 2026 review: three deletions from the MSCI ACWI IMI index, Strategy A (USA), Yellow Cake (UK) and Metaplanet (Japan); effective Dec 1, 20266
Each row is one MSCI standard announcement or index-review publication, summarised in Bittery’s words; the footnote links the document. A consultation is MSCI asking the investment community for feedback on a proposal before deciding. Strategy’s own statement is in the last section.7 Other index providers (S&P, Nasdaq, FTSE Russell) are not covered here because their own rule documents were not available to read. Observed facts, not a forecast.
MSCI’s Global Investable Market Indexes (GIMI) exclude investment funds and business development companies, so that they measure operating businesses.4 Some investors told MSCI that companies whose main activity is accumulating bitcoin or other digital assets, known as digital asset treasury companies (DATCOs), look like investment funds.3 An index provider’s eligibility rules decide which companies index funds that track its indexes can hold.
2025
The 50% proposal
On October 10, 2025 MSCI extended a consultation on excluding companies whose digital asset holdings are “50% or more of their total assets”, and published a preliminary list of affected securities.1 While it was open, MSCI stopped increasing the share counts and inclusion factors used for index weights for Metaplanet and Capital B, and deferred additions and size-segment moves for other securities on the list.12
Jan 2026
No exclusion in February
On January 6, 2026 MSCI decided “not to implement” the exclusion at the February 2026 review. It said DATCOs may be one subset of a wider group of investment-oriented entities and that telling them apart from operating companies that hold digital assets “requires further research”, so it planned a broader consultation. The interim treatment for the preliminary list stayed in place.3
Aug 2026
The non-operating company screens
The August 3, 2026 proposal applied a core screen to all companies to see whether the issuer has substantial operating assets. An issuer that fails would face an exclusion screen of five financial ratios, and would be ineligible if flagged on four of the five.4 The October 15 result kept this design: new and existing companies are judged on their two most recent annual filing periods, and a current constituent is removed only if it fails in each of them.5
Nov 2026
What happened at the November review
MSCI’s October 15 announcement set the changes for the November 2026 review, effective at the close of November 30, and ended the 2025 interim measures.5 On November 11 MSCI reported the first application of the methodology: three deletions from the MSCI ACWI IMI, Strategy A, Yellow Cake and Metaplanet, with changes effective December 1.6
Company view
What Strategy’s filing says
Strategy’s 10-Q says that on October 15, 2026 MSCI announced the new eligibility criteria for “non-operating companies” and that, “based on these criteria, we expect our class A common stock to be excluded” from the MSCI indexes in the November 2026 review. It adds that exclusion “could cause index funds, institutional investors” and others tracking an index “to sell our class A common stock”, and that other index publishers could adopt similar rules.7 MSCI describes index turnover as “the proportion of assets that should be purchased in a portfolio replicating the index”.6 This page records the decisions and says nothing about what prices will do.